Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

Welcome! If this is your first time here, please refer to the help section (click here), and the posting guidelines (click here) to help you, and the rest of the community, get the most out of this forum.

Current User: Guest login Northern Alberta Birding HotlineLogin register Northern Alberta Birding HotlineRegister
Please consider registering

Search Forums:


searchicon Northern Alberta Birding Hotline 




UserPost

11:51am
17 Dec 2010


ann

Guest

 Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

Watched a falcon from the kitchen window (west of Edmonton) today. Perched high on an Aspen at the edge of the green space, nearby bird feeders. Two magpies eventually moved it off. Falcon shape, big “shoulders” pointed wings almost as long as the pointed (while perched) tail. Just barely shorter in length than the magpies. Light colour underside, dark greyish brown uppers, wings darker toward the tips, barely visible dark banding on tail, lighter over the shoulder toward the back of the neck, very slight amount of lighter “eyebrow”. Juvenile bird? When it flew the wing beat was relatively slow, 3 beats and then a pause, 3 beats and then a pause. Too big for a Merlin?? Too small for a Gyrfalcon?? Goshawk?? What are your thoughts on this?

Thanks, Ann

8:43am
20 Dec 2010


ann

Guest

 Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

Got another look at this bird today. Not a falcon. It's an Accipiter. What winter residents do we have besides N. Goshawk? Ann

7:15pm
25 Dec 2010


Tiina Payson

Guest

 Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

Hi Ann,

Check out the following site to help you decide if you perhaps saw a Sharp-shinned or Cooper's hawk or Merlin: http://www.allaboutbirds.org/guide/Sharp-shinned_Hawk/id

Where it also offers some tips on telling the difference between them:  ”

Similar Species

  • Very similar in plumage to Cooper's HawkCooper's Hawkhas proportionately longer tail, rounded at the tip. Cooper's Hawk is more robust and has a proportionately larger head. Adult Cooper's Hawk has a dark cap that contrasts with its back. Juvenile Cooper's Hawk has less streaking underneath and more white on the tip of the tail. In flight, the larger head of the Cooper's Hawk is apparent, sticking out farther in front of the wings. For more information separating the two species click here.
  • Merlin is similar to juvenile, but its wingtips nearly reach the end of the tail, not less than half way down as in Sharp-shinned HawkMerlin has long, pointed wings in flight, not rounded.

5:54pm
01 Jan 2011


Jim Lange

Moderator

Edmonton, AB

 Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

posts 177

Hi Ann,
Thanks for the report of the accipiter. The description and location would suggest to me an imm. Northern Goshawk. They are the largest of the accipiters

addpost Northern Alberta Birding HotlineReply to Post


Reply to Topic: falcon ID?

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Topic Reply:

Save New PostSmileys

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
5 + 3
   

 
sf confused Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf cry Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf embarassed Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf frown Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf laugh Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf smile Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf surprised Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf wink Northern Alberta Birding Hotline sf yell Northern Alberta Birding Hotline

feedtopic Northern Alberta Birding Hotline  top Northern Alberta Birding Hotline


share save 120 16 Northern Alberta Birding Hotline